i am very curious to see whats underneath the original paint. may be i like what i see and do not need to paint it all, may be.

It has been said that you can remove the handle and sandblast it to expose the metal underneath. It would probably match your aluminum fascia in terms of color, but its shape has those curved features that are meant to match the original fascia, so it might or might not be what you like.

What about making your own aluminum handle to go with your fascia?