hard drive & OS compatibility

Posted by: Anonymous

hard drive & OS compatibility - 31/12/2002 20:32

I've got a new Western Digital hard drive. On the box it says it's designed for Win XP, Win 2000, Win ME, and Mac.
Does this mean it probably won't work for Windows 98?

The system requirements say: IDA-ATA interface (40-pin connector) and Ultra ATA-capable system.

Do hard drives generally work with any OS or do I need to find one made specially for Windows 98?
Posted by: mtempsch

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 31/12/2002 20:48

Normally they work with any OS - there might be issues with how large the OS "sees" the drive to be. Don't recall what, if any, limitations 98 had on that front. Older BIOS might also report an incorrect size to the OS...

/Michael
Posted by: andym

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 05:39

Methinks you're just limited by the size restrictions of FAT32. Is it something like 32 Gig? I use NTFS now under 2000 so it's no longer a problem.
Posted by: BartDG

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 06:07

It is 32 gig, but that's not a restriction of FAT32. FAT32 actually works up 'till some terabytes.

The 32 gig restriction was coded into win2000 by the MS programmers to "force" people to start using NTFS (which doesn't have this restriction) instead of FAT32.
Posted by: image

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 11:10

i'm sure that if you use partition magic, you can get around the restriction in windows. i think it only prevents you from creating, not from actually having a 32gig+ partition
Posted by: BartDG

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 13:35

You are correct. This does work. Also, you can create a bigger partition on a win98 system. It only doesn't work in win2000 and XP (I believe)

Win2000 will work great with fat32 partitions greater than 32gig, but won't allow for them to be created.
Posted by: Anonymous

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 14:00

It is 40 gigs. Is this partitioning magic you speak of a hard thing to figure out?
Posted by: StigOE

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 14:00

You can't have bigger drives in Win2000 than 137GB unless you use SP3 and a registry hack, but I'm not sure if that is for FAT32 or NTFS. A friend of mine ran into that when he wanted to install his new 200GB drive....

Stig
Posted by: Ezekiel

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 14:32

Nope. Very easy. But it is about $70 IIRC.
edit: link here .

-Zeke
Posted by: BartDG

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 01/01/2003 16:18

You can't have bigger drives in Win2000 than 137GB unless you use SP3 and a registry hack

I've heard about this, but haven't reached that limit myself...yet. For future use it would come in handy to know what this reg hack is. Do you have a link for this? (or is simply installing SP3 sufficient?)
Thx!
Posted by: StigOE

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 02/01/2003 06:36

Searching for 137GB on micro$oft gave me these two links:

48-bit LBA Support for ATAPI Disk Drives in Windows 2000 and How to Enable 48-bit Logical Block Addressing Support for ATAPI Disk Drives in Windows XP

Stig
Posted by: Phoenix42

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 02/01/2003 09:45

a windows 98 boot disk and you can creat the >32gig partition
once you boot back into 2k it will be quite happy to use it
Posted by: BartDG

Re: hard drive & OS compatibility - 02/01/2003 12:11

Thanks a lot! This info will sure come in hand some day soon now.