I guess the good thing is, if I can't find it, insurance should cover it minus $200 deductible. I'm not sure if the price they pay will be the original price ($300) or the current asking price ($700+) though.

The CDs aren't covered by my car insurance, but items stolen from my car are covered under homeowner's insurance (minus $500 deductible). Unfortunately, it appear that they specifically exclude games from compensation, though I cannot fathom the justification.

-Biscuits